Passive investing is increasingly viewed as an interesting option in an ever-dynamic environment. The financial markets can be quite volatile and, at times, unpredictable. Simple and relatively inexpensive, passive mutual funds provide an avenue to tap market growth without the active management and related expenses common in many traditional funds. These mutual funds track certain market indices. By mirroring the performance of such benchmarks, these funds provide broad market exposure, thereby reducing the risk associated with individual stock selection.
In this comprehensive guide, we go in-depth into passive mutual funds in India, weighing the pros and cons and how they can suit your investment strategy.
Passive funds, as the name suggests, are passively managed and strive to mimic the performance of a particular index, such as the S&P BSE 500 or Nifty 50. They hold a fixed portfolio of stocks per the index's composition.
Passive funds are cheap and straightforward, but they do not have the flexibility of an actively managed fund. As the awareness of passive investing increases, Indian investors, too, have started liking the benefits that come with passive funds in the form of lower cost, diversification, and alignment with long-term market trends.
The different types of passive funds are given below:
Type of Fund | Characteristics | Objectives | Examples |
---|---|---|---|
ETF: (Exchange-Traded Funds) | Traded on stock exchanges Combines benefits of stocks and mutual funds Tracks underlying indices (equities, bonds, commodities) Requires a Demat account for transactions |
Provide exposure to various assets Offer flexibility and liquidity |
Nifty 50 ETF, SBI ETF Gold |
Index Funds | Replicates the performance of a specific market index Passively constructs portfolios by mirroring the index No attempt to outperform the market Blends active and passive strategies Investment strategy based on rules-based principles Considers factors like value, quality, or momentum |
Match the performance of a chosen benchmark Provide broad market exposure Deliver better risk-adjusted returns compared to passive investing |
HDFC Index Fund, UTI Nifty Index Fund |
Smart Beta Funds | Invests in multiple mutual funds rather than individual securities Provides diversification across asset classes, sectors, and markets Fund manager selects and manages passive funds |
Diversify portfolios Reduce risk exposure Align with the investor's risk profile |
ICICI Prudential Nifty Low Vol 30 ETF, DSP Equal Nifty 50 Fund |
Fund of Funds (FoF) | Invests in multiple mutual funds rather than individual securities Provides diversification across asset classes, sectors, and markets Fund manager selects and manages passive funds |
Diversify portfolios Reduce risk exposure Align with the investor's risk profile |
Franklin India Multi-Asset Solution Fund, ICICI Prudential Passive Strategy Fund |
Passive investing in India has undergone a sea of change over the last two and a half decades from only two index funds, Nifty and Sensex, being launched in the late 90s to today, when index funds and ETFs are tracking across market capitalisations, various investment factors like momentum, value, quality, and growth, and sector funds.
Internationally, several fund houses offer passive funds exposure to various international indices. On the fixed-income side, passive funds have also been launched in segments relating to G-Secs and liquid funds. In commodities, there are passive funds for gold and silver, among others.
Institutional investors-through pension funds, insurance companies, and corporate treasuries-continue to dominate the passive fund space. These funds are slowly making their presence felt among retail investors.
Pros | Cons |
---|---|
Low costs due to lower expense ratios. | Limited flexibility to adapt to market changes. |
Simple to understand as they mirror an index. | Tied to market performance, with no chance to outperform. |
Provide broad market exposure and diversification. | No downside protection during market downturns. |
Transparent, with regularly published holdings. | Potential for small discrepancies due to tracking error. |
Greater tax efficiency due to lower turnover. | No opportunity for skilled management to outperform. |
Active funds are investment funds wherein the manager actively selects securities to buy, retain, or sell so that the fund may perform better than the market. The best-case scenario desired is a return in excess of what the benchmark index can provide. Research, analysis, and strategic changes are crucial for a fund manager. These offer more significant return opportunities but are considerably riskier due to extensive buying and selling and calls on market timing.
A comparison of active and passive funds is drawn to help understand some of the key differences between them:
Feature | Active Funds | Passive Funds |
---|---|---|
Management | They are managed by fund managers who actively pick securities. | Track a specific index or benchmark passively. |
Style | Aim to outperform the market through selective investment. | Aim to replicate the performance of an index. |
Objective | Discretionary; based on research and analysis. | Rules-based; follows the index's composition. |
Investment Strategy | Discretionary; based on research and analysis. | Rules-based; follows the index's composition. |
Fees | Generally higher due to management fees and active trading. | Typically lower due to minimal trading and management. |
Performance | Can outperform or underperform the market. | Typically matches the performance of the index. |
Risk | Higher due to manager's decisions and market timing. | Lower, as they mirror the index's risk profile. |
Transparency | Less transparent; holdings and strategies may be less visible. | More transparent; holdings are usually published regularly. |
Tax Efficiency | Can be less tax-efficient due to frequent trading. | More tax-efficient due to lower turnover. |
Diversification | Depends on the fund manager's strategy; may be less diversified. | Usually highly diversified as they replicate indices. |
Investment Horizon | Often suited for investors seeking higher returns and willing to take on more risk. | Suitable for long-term investors seeking steady returns. |
Flexibility | Can adapt to changing market conditions and trends. | Less flexible; strictly follows the index. |
Historical Performance | Can show significant variability in returns. | Generally provides steady, predictable returns based on the index performance. |
Data from the Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI) shows that 106 different new fund offers, or NFOs, were launched by various mutual fund houses in the first seven months of 2024. Of these new schemes introduced, 63 passive schemes were launched in just seven months, against 51 passive schemes launched in the previous year.
The choice of passive funds is not highly relevant compared to the choice of active funds. For example, the best-performing active large-cap fund over a five-year term is at 19% CAGR, while the worst has been at 14% CAGR. All 50 Nifty ETFs over a comparable period have returned something around 15% CAGR, with minor differences in returns.
Here is why passive funds can be the right investment for you:
Passive equity funds are taxed the same as active equity funds or equity shares. The short-term capital gain is taxed at a uniform rate of 15%. If you sell your passive equity fund units after a holding period of at least a year, you will trigger long-term capital gains. The latter is exempt from tax for up to ₹1 lakh per year. All long-term capital gains exceeding this limit are taxed at 10% without any indexation benefit.
Listed below are some of the passive funds that have generated excellent returns in the last three years:
Passive Mutual Fund | Expense Ratio | Three-Year Returns | Asset in crore |
---|---|---|---|
Kotak Nifty PSU Bank ETF | 0.49% | 42.85% | 1,205.22 |
Nippon India ETF Nifty PSU Bank BeES | 0.49% | 42.81% | 2,189.26 |
Nippon India Nifty Smallcap 250 Index Fund | 0.88% | 31.86% | 1,054.18 |
Motilal Oswal Nifty Smallcap 250 Index Fund | 1.04% | 31.85% | 603.71 |
Motilal Oswal Nifty Midcap 100 ETF | 0.20% | 30.43% | 341.91 |
Passive funds are ideal for new investors who want to experience growth parallel to the indices. Some key points to remember are:
Passive mutual funds have gained immense popularity in the Indian investment scenario. It is an offering that presents investors with a straightforward, less expensive, and diversified way of investing. Tracking specific indices, these funds give broad exposure to securities to cut risks associated with selecting individual stocks.
Passive funds have been one of the popular vehicles for Indian investors seeking long-term returns due to their relatively lower expense ratio and tax efficiency. It is, however, essential that an investment decision be made with careful consideration of investment goals, risk tolerance, and passive fund characteristics.
Interested in investing in mutual funds? Explore the Choice platform to find different types of mutual funds designed to optimise returns.